Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules

Recommendation 2024-1, Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules – provides that, when drafting a statute that provides for judicial review of agency rules, Congress ordinarily should provide that rules promulgated using notice-and-comment procedures are subject to direct review by a court of appeals. The recommendation also identifies common statutory ambiguities that Congress should avoid in drafting new or amending existing statutes that provide for judicial review of agency actions.

Contacts:

Implementation Contact

Committee:

Final Recommendation:

Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules

Recommendation number
2024-1
Adoption Date

Project Documents

Name Committee Type Date File
Agenda for Judicial Review Committee March 20, 2024 Meeting Committee on Judicial Review Agenda Download Agenda for Judicial Review Committee March 20, 2024 Meeting
Agenda for Judicial Review Committee April 3, 2024, Meeting Committee on Judicial Review Agenda Download Agenda for Judicial Review Committee April 3, 2024, Meeting
Agenda for Judicial Review Committee April 25, 2024, Meeting Committee on Judicial Review Agenda Download Agenda for Judicial Review Committee April 25, 2024, Meeting
Agenda for Judicial Review Committee May 2, 2024, Meeting Committee on Judicial Review Agenda Download Agenda for Judicial Review Committee May 2, 2024, Meeting
Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules Request for Proposal RFP Download Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules Request for Proposal
Choice of Forum Recommendation - For Plenary - Redline Committee on Judicial Review Recommendation Download Choice of Forum Recommendation - For Plenary - Redline
Choice of Forum - Draft Recommendation for April 3, 2024, Meeting Committee on Judicial Review Recommendation Download Choice of Forum - Draft Recommendation for April 3, 2024, Meeting
Choice of Forum - Draft Recommendation for April 25, 2024, Meeting Committee on Judicial Review Recommendation Download Choice of Forum - Draft Recommendation for April 25, 2024, Meeting
Choice of Forum - Draft Recommendation for May 2, 2024, Meeting Committee on Judicial Review Recommendation Download Choice of Forum - Draft Recommendation for May 2, 2024, Meeting
Choice of Forum - Proposed Recommendation from Committee Committee on Judicial Review Recommendation Download Choice of Forum - Proposed Recommendation from Committee
Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules (Final Report) Committee on Judicial Review Report Download Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules (Final Report)
Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules (Draft Report) Committee on Judicial Review Report Download Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules (Draft Report)
Comment from Special Counsel Jeffrey Lubbers on Choice of Forum Comment Download Comment from Special Counsel Jeffrey Lubbers on Choice of Forum
Comment from Public Member Jennifer Dickey on Choice of Forum Comment Download Comment from Public Member Jennifer Dickey on Choice of Forum
Comment from Senior Fellow Ronald M. Levin on Choice of Forum Comment Download Comment from Senior Fellow Ronald M. Levin on Choice of Forum
Comment from Senior Fellow Alan Morrison on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules Committee on Judicial Review Comment Download Comment from Senior Fellow Alan Morrison on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules
Comment from Senior Fellow Ronald M. Levin on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules Committee on Judicial Review Comment Download Comment from Senior Fellow Ronald M. Levin on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules
Comment from CFPB on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules Committee on Judicial Review Comment Download Comment from CFPB on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules
Comment from Senior Fellow Alan Morrison on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules Committee on Judicial Review Comment Download Comment from Senior Fellow Alan Morrison on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules

No events found.

Committee on Judicial Review Meeting #3 (Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules)

-
Location name
ACUS will be hosting this committee meeting remotely. Members of the public interested in participating should contact Kazia Nowacki at knowacki@acus.gov to RSVP and request attendance information.

Committee on Judicial Review Meeting #1 (Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules)

-
Location name
ACUS will be hosting this committee meeting remotely. Members of the public interested in participating should contact Kazia Nowacki at knowacki@acus.gov to RSVP and request attendance information.

Committee on Judicial Review Workshop (Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules)

-
Location name
ACUS will be hosting this committee meeting remotely. Members of the public interested in participating should contact Kazia Nowacki at knowacki@acus.gov to RSVP and request attendance information.
  .