Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules

This project will study and, as appropriate, make recommendations to guide Congress in determining the appropriate forum and venue for judicial review of agency rules—with respect to both existing programs and programs established in the future. Topics it will address include: (a) contexts in which agency rules should be subject to direct review by the courts of appeals rather than the district courts; (b) contexts in which Congress should consider limiting the venue for judicial review of rules beyond what the ordinary rules of venue would permit; (c) contexts in which the courts should consolidate multiple challenges to a single rule in a single case in a single court, and the processes for doing so; and (d) common ambiguities and other drafting problems in the statutes governing the choice of forum for judicial review of agency rules.

Joseph Mead (Georgetown Law Institute for Constitutional Advocacy and Protection) is serving as the consultant for this project.

Contacts:

Staff Counsel

Committee:

Project Documents

Name Committee Type Date File
Agenda for Judicial Review Committee March 20, 2024 Meeting Committee on Judicial Review Agenda Download Agenda for Judicial Review Committee March 20, 2024 Meeting
Agenda for Judicial Review Committee April 3, 2024, Meeting Committee on Judicial Review Agenda Download Agenda for Judicial Review Committee April 3, 2024, Meeting
Agenda for Judicial Review Committee April 25, 2024, Meeting Committee on Judicial Review Agenda Download Agenda for Judicial Review Committee April 25, 2024, Meeting
Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules Request for Proposal RFP Download Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules Request for Proposal
Choice of Forum - Draft Recommendation for April 3, 2024, Meeting Committee on Judicial Review Recommendation Download Choice of Forum - Draft Recommendation for April 3, 2024, Meeting
Choice of Forum - Draft Recommendation for April 25, 2024, Meeting Committee on Judicial Review Recommendation Download Choice of Forum - Draft Recommendation for April 25, 2024, Meeting
Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules (Draft Report) Report Download Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules (Draft Report)
Comment from Senior Fellow Alan Morrison on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules Committee on Judicial Review Comment Download Comment from Senior Fellow Alan Morrison on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules
Comment from Senior Fellow Ronald M. Levin on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules Committee on Judicial Review Comment Download Comment from Senior Fellow Ronald M. Levin on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules
Comment from CFPB on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules Committee on Judicial Review Comment Download Comment from CFPB on Choice of Forum for Judicial Review of Agency Rules
  .